The Writing Page | Part One | Advice That Authors Should Reconsider & Revise

I have been reading a lot of writing articles and advice videos lately that have gotten me to consider all the bits of wisdom out there for writers just starting out. This led me to want to write a piece on all the bad advice writers should revise and reconsider ….

There is a lot of them out there and this series will be broken into two parts. In today’s blog post, I am discussing five pieces of advice that are not so helpful. I hope you enjoy the article and please leave in the comments below the worst writing/reading advice you have ever received. I would love to hear about them. Thank you!

#1 – Writers should read everything they can get their hands on, including stuff they know is terrible or that they will hate/dislike! … 

  • The problem with this piece of advice is super simple. Life is too short to be wasting your time reading material that you know is terrible or that you won’t like at all. This should be revised to say writers should read a lot. There is wisdom behind the advice that writers should be avid readers. It does help tremendously, but as readers, we are going to come across stuff that is terrible anyway. Why go in search of it? Read as much as possible and be diverse in your reading choices; however, writers should not force themselves to read anything that they already know they will not enjoy. There is no point in that and it is absolutely useless.

#2 – Writers should write every day 

  • There is nothing wrong with this piece of advice and it is a great one to try to follow; however, it is not always reasonable. Many of us have full-time day jobs, careers to fulfill, and school to attend. These must come first. We have a family, friends, and children to care for and look after. Writing every day is not always going to happen and although the advice is excellent in theory, it is not always realistic. A more reasonable approach to this advice is to write as often as possible and do something productive towards your writing goal daily. This can be accomplished in many ways like watching a quick writing video for tips and advice on something you’re stuck with or for general knowledge towards your goal of becoming an accomplished writer. On a ten-minute break at work, read a writing advice article on your phone. Productivity can be found in a lot of ways, such as jotting down some quick ideas or notes running through your brain. Get creative!

#3 – Don’t start off big by writing novels, but begin with much smaller formats like flash fiction or short stories until you have progressed enough to go bigger. 

  • This piece of writing advice truly hits home for me because it is a bit of logic I have followed for the last year as I struggle to develop my writing skills through short stories, poetry, blogging, and practice. I honestly don’t think trying to stick with small writing has made a huge difference for me as a writer. That is not where my improvements have stemmed from. I have become a better writer slowly by just simply writing, the feedback everyone here on the blog provides me when I share my work, reading as often as possible, and watching writing tutorials. I would go as far as to argue by trying to keep my writing small, it has actually been a hindrance in my progress towards becoming a novelist. If you write only short stories, then you are going to master writing short stories. It is very different from writing a novel. This is why I think writers should write what they want. Go big right off the bat. There is no point in not doing so and it will help and give you the ability to learn through experience. Practice and writing are what will make your skill grow not limiting it because of fear or insecurity. If a writer truly wants to write a book, then not feeling ready is no excuse. Dive right in! Only good tings can come from it! A writer can learn quite a lot by writing a terrible novel rather than never trying. Never hold back because the will stall progress very quickly.

Please Note: I am not saying a writer cannot write both short stories and novels. I am saying write whatever it is you want to write! That is where a writer learns! If someone wants to be a novelist. Then write novels and learn from it. Never hold back by saying you cannot achieve it. That you are not ready. I promise you are! 

#4 – Take all writing advice with a grain of salt. 

  • This one is actually a bit more complicated than what is implied. There are circumstances when this should be followed and others when it is okay to ignore it altogether. I will start when it is NOT okay to take advice with a grain of salt. If a writer wants to be taken seriously and produce material that engages the readers, there are rules that MUST be followed. The rules of grammar, spelling, and punctuation are one clear example of this. Writers have to know their business. It is about professionalism. Would you show up to an interview in a BBQ stained t-shirt, swim trunks, and flip-flops? Not likely, most would adhere to the proper business attire and present themselves a bit more formally. The same principle applies to writing of all sorts. There is a standard that should always be adhered to if a writer wants to be published and have their work recognized with good feedback. Some circumstances when writers should take advice with a grain of salt gear towards the artsy aspects of writing and less with the technical side. There is a standard that should always be adhered to if a writer wants to be published and have their work recognized with good feedback. Some circumstances when writers should take advice with a grain of salt gear towards the artsy aspects of writing and less with the technical side. If a writer is told for example a piece of advice such as “Writers should always outline” and yet they have always written without needing to do so. Then by all means that writer should do what works for them and their craft. That is just one example. Please always keep in mind that writing is a very technical craft with laws that should not be ignored and at the same time is a very creative outlet with vast amounts of room to make creative decisions that will be best for that piece of work. The balance is a very fine line and writers must use their own judgement about the information they receive.

#5 – Writing dialogue is about replicating human speech as accurately and realistically as possible in every scenario . HINT: NO IT’S NOT! 

  • If anyone here on my blog has read any of my short stories, then they know I struggle with writing natural and cohesive dialogue for my characters. The above piece of advice irks me to the extreme because it is simply not what I have been taught and honestly the wisdom is highly misleading especially if the writer is just starting out and follows the advice in the most literal of ways. Dialogue serves a number of specific purposes like moving the story along, providing information, character development. There is simply too much mundane speech and conversation people have every day that is boring and meaningless. Writers who follow this advice too closely will wind up with a messy, over-wordy, and boring manuscript filled with useless conversation that does nothing for the story. All dialogue and any word written in a story should have a purpose behind it that grows the characters, plot, setting, and story. It should move the readers along as smoothly as possible and create some value for them. Who wants to read a book filled with endless ” Hello, how are you?” “I am good” “Great” “What did you do today?” “Nothing much” etc etc etc. Please have a point to it all, unless the purpose to make the readers bored to tears. This is not to say that writers shouldn’t be aware of the realism of it all. Create characters that behave in an understandable and natural way. The character’s voice should be realistic and easy to relate with.

Please stay tuned next week for part 2 of writing advice author should reconsider. I look forward to getting that posted as soon as possible! Thank you for reading! 


Facebook Page:

Facebook Group




30 thoughts on “The Writing Page | Part One | Advice That Authors Should Reconsider & Revise

  1. Love this post! Writing advice is both helpful and needs to be applied carefully. You’ve done a nice job explaining why it’s not a “one size fits all” situation. I agree that reading widely does not mean reading things that are awful! Life is too short for that. I have read 50 books so far this year and only a few that were not very good. If I’m not enjoying it or getting something out of it, I put it aside.
    Regarding dialogue, may I suggest audiobooks as a way to study dialogue. If it’s done well, and the reader is good, it allows me practice my own craft.


  2. This is a good post. I especially like the advice around writing what you want to write. I love novels. I want to write a novel I feel like publishing. So, I practice writing novels. I haven’t finished one in a couple of years, but I feel one developing in my head. The previous five I finished, while not ready for publishing, certainly taught me a lot.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: Thoughts on Thursday – So You Want To Be A Writer Part One – Paula Acton

  4. I love your arguments, especially on no.1! The worst advice I’ve heard: 1) write like the best-seller writers, 2) research stories that are on trend, and 3) make stories that inspire people. But I write because I love creating my own world and my characters! Not to win people nor to copy others. Bad advice can paralyze our creativity, make us feel hopeless with our writing.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. This sounds like advice from people who don’t actually write. The only advice I take from this is to try writing everyday, because it helps me build up a good habit even if it’s only 300 words a day. If I’m not writing, I’m probably reading or making outlines for things I plan to write.

    Liked by 2 people

    • I think trying to write everyday or as often as possible is the best way to build that skill, and I agree. The advice does sound like from people who don’t really write; however, there is some merit in them if used right. The problem is most of the advice listed needs to be reworked in order for the writer to find some use in it. Thanks for your input and reading my post N.E ! 🙂


  6. Great advice! I would also like to add to the dialogue point. If someone recorded me speaking to people for a good length of time and then transcribed it all exactly, they’d notice (in addition to normal pleasantries) a lot of filler words (“like” “eh” “uh”), incomplete sentences, irrelevant chatter etc. that is perfectly natural but wouldn’t add anything to the story.

    Liked by 3 people

    • Oh great input! I couldn’t agree more. I don’t mind a little bit if it is showing the character’s voice and giving them uniqueness but yes, writers have to be careful how they present that. Thank you for reading and for your comment! ❤

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Number three irks me because different writers are better at writing different things. To tell a writer to concentrate on short stories or flash fiction, which may not be their specialty, is counterproductive. Also, some writers think of these things in terms of word count, which is misleading–it’s what you do with the words. I have read short stories that have way more information and have made more of an impact, that a novella or a novel. Frankly, not all writers can write all the things. Blurbs, flash fiction, a scene, a play, a novella, a novel…these are all different skill sets as far as I’m concerned. One can hone them, but very rarely is an author good at all of them.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Oh I couldn’t agree more and I have been following this advice for a while now, simply just writing short stories to become a better writer but what I really want to do is write a novel. I have written lots of short stories and one non-fiction book, but haven’t really allowed myself to dive into novel writing. That has changed recently and am working on my first fiction novel. It all comes from practice and learning! thanks for your comment! ❤ ❤ ❤

      Liked by 2 people

  8. Great advice, I get into the habit of writing a paragraph everyday but soon go back into writing only when I feel something I need to say. I need to take this sage advice and DO IT.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. I am taking a fiction class this semester in college and honestly, I think the “writing every day” advice has helped me a lot. Even if it’s just a paragraph, I’ve found that just the act of sitting down in front of my laptop and doing it helps me to conjure some ideas. And then as I write, I come up with more ideas which I flesh-out the next day. I just make a point to write for a bit every day until I run out of writing energy which is anywhere from twenty minutes to an hour. It helps me at least get a rough draft on the table that I can always return to and re-write and revise later on. Steven King in his book “On Writing” as well as Anne Lamott, also recommend this.

    Liked by 3 people

    • I agree. There is nothing better to assist in making your writing stronger by actually writing, and kudos for your devotion. I just meant I don’t feel like this advice is always practical and know many writers feel guilty and bad when they don’t manage to write every day and if your unable, it is okay! ❤

      Liked by 1 person

  10. Your point about taking writing advice with a grain of salt: yes, but understand what works and what you can take from that advice. Understanding grammar is essential, but it’s also good to know when to abandon grammar, and to what purpose. Writing poor for effect is just ugly. To your point about replicating dialogue. Ugh. Writing the way people talk is one thing, but verbatim transcription is a snoozefest.
    Enjoying your points so far.

    Liked by 3 people

  11. Worst writing advice I see/hear is write what you know. I write science fiction and fantasy. I create my worlds.

    I agree with your dialogue comment but would add dialogue should be understandable, but not every comment is a complete sentence.

    Liked by 3 people

    • Yes, I’ve heard that one before. Writing what you know is very limiting and can hinder a writer from their full creative potential. I will be talking about this in part 2, and love your advice about not every dialogue comment should be a complete sentence! Thanks for reading and your comments! ♦♠♣

      Liked by 2 people

  12. I must not read enough advice to have terrible advice to comment on!

    These are good pointers, Samantha. There is so much advice and tips stuff out there a potential writer could get lost trying to “learn the craft” without ever writing anything. My only advice is to write often. I go through periods of intense activity followed by long periods of writing nothing. I need to be more consistent.

    Keep writing and inspiring!

    Liked by 3 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s